US court orders the .com domain name of a Dutch-hosted website to be blocked

Digital autonomy is about domain names as well

Lady Justice in front of a Texan flag

When choosing a domain name, you need to decide what internet extension you want for your new domain. In the Netherlands, .nl is an obvious choice, but another extension – such as .ai or .tv – can sometimes be a better fit for a particular product or service. And, whichever extension you choose, your choice implies certain dependencies.

A court in Texas, USA, recently made a ruling that illustrates how domain name-related dependencies extend beyond reliance on the extension itself. The case involved a domain name with the .com extension, which hundreds of thousands of Dutch people and organisations use for their primary domains. The Texas court ordered .com’s operator Verisign to intervene against a domain name used by an ‘adult content’ provider (a Luxembourg company whose website was then hosted in the Netherlands).

How far does a Texas court’s authority extend?

The case centred on a breach of Texas’s age verification law, which requires explicit content providers to check that their visitors are adults. The owner of the site in question wasn’t doing that. Nor did they appear in court to fight their case. So the judge handed down a default judgment. As a result, the fundamental legal question of whether a Texas court has jurisdiction over a Luxembourg company whose website is hosted in the Netherlands was never addressed. Under US law, a foreign party must have a demonstrable connection to a state for that state’s court to assert jurisdiction. On its own, the fact that a website is accessible from the relevant state is not sufficient grounds for claiming jurisdiction.

A European website hit by US intervention

When the site’s owner ignored an earlier order, Texas decided to take an unusual route. Instead of continuing to pursue the owner, the court handed down an order to Verisign, the registry that operates the .com domain globally. Hence, the focus of enforcement shifted from the alleged offender to the infrastructure operator. In response to the order, Verisign changed the domain name’s status to serverHold, meaning that it was no longer findable. In other words, Verisign intervened at the Domain Name System (DNS) level: the domain name remained registered, but was rendered unfindable in the .com DNS. So the domain name couldn’t be translated into an IP address, and no one anywhere in the world could reach the website by using the domain name.

Because the order addressed only the registry, the registrar and registrant were completely outside its scope and therefore powerless to oppose its implementation. Meanwhile, Verisign, as a US company, had no choice but to comply.

Ruling has global effect

Although the case concerned an offence under Texan law, the effect of the ruling was felt worldwide. The registry-level switch to serverHold status meant that the domain name was no longer included in the .com zone file. Consequently, no one anywhere in the world could reach the website by using the domain name.

In other words, intervention based on the laws of a single US state affected internet users everywhere, because the generic TLD’s registry just so happened to be in the US. And rules that apply in a single US state had repercussions for registrants and internet users all around the globe.

The case therefore illustrates that registrants whose domain names have extensions managed by US registries can, under certain circumstances, find themselves at the mercy of US courts. Even if their websites are hosted outside the US.

Little coverage in the Netherlands

In the Netherlands, the case attracted relatively little attention. The lack of interest was probably linked to the nature of the website and previous reports that its operator was under criminal investigation. Nevertheless, the ruling is very relevant here in the Netherlands, where more than 2 million .com domain names are in use. We now know that those names can be affected by what a US court decides.

What does the ruling mean for registrants?

The key question is, therefore, what implications could this case have going forwards? Could similar intervention be requested in disputes of other kinds? The probability of a similar future request being granted depends on the facts of the case, the applicable legislation and the view taken by the US court. However, little influence can be exerted from the Netherlands where any of those matters is concerned. Anyone wishing to manage their risk exposure might do well to consider registering a domain name with a Dutch or European extension as well as having a .com domain. Domain names with .nl and .eu extensions are overseen by SIDN and EURid, respectively. Neither of those organisations is under to US jurisdiction and cannot therefore be ordered to intervene by an American court.

Digital autonomy is about domain names as well

The case highlights a point that’s sometimes overlooked when the subject of digital autonomy is discussed. Even if hosted entirely outside the US, a website can be reliant on infrastructure that’s under US jurisdiction. That’s the case not only with sites that use the .com extension, but also those using various other generic extensions, including .org and .info. What’s more, the dependency extends beyond domain names. Anyone relying on US cloud infrastructure, a US content delivery network or a US DNS resolver is in a very similar legal position: all such services fall under the same regime. A website that appears outwardly European can in fact be vulnerable due to underlying infrastructural dependencies. The Texas court ruling therefore adds an urgent, substantive dimension to the wider debate regarding digital autonomy, jurisdiction and how the global internet infrastructure is governed. As long as that infrastructure is concentrated in American hands, the influence of the US courts is not an exceptional phenomenon but a fact of life for European registrants.